Could Discipline, Structure, Independence, and Creativity Coexist?

Recently I've been thinking a lot about childrens' need for structure; structures allow kids to know if they're doing well in class; it also lets students know what to expect - it makes class feel safer and more predictable. Through structures, kids become "cultured" (they learn what behaviors are acceptable or not).

Yet, I also read "School as the Product of the Adult Fantasy of a World Without Children" (from I'm Only Bleeding, Alan A. Block), which describes how education smothers the imaginative, playful aspect of childhood. This goes hand in hand with one of my favorite books, The Little Prince (Antoine de Saint-Exupéry), which juxtaposes the perspective of the adult (rigid, calculated, stressed) with the perspective of the child (innocent, hopeful, fresh). While in graduate school with no real teaching experience, I veered on the side of emphasizing creativity/free-thought/less-structured (somewhat idealistic, to say the least) - I dreamed of leading classes based on open-projects and Socratic seminars (the language barrier does not help in this area, haha).

However, at this point in time, I feel that I'm beginning to see the need for MORE structure: I have encountered an episode where I was stressed and appalled by the way my middle school students behaved (I was supervising them when they had some free-time; it was like a battle royale - kids yelling at each other, then screaming louder to try getting their way, lots of pushing and shoving, defacing property that isn't theirs, etc.); this was weeks after "telling" them that they are expected to respect the teacher, the space, and their peers.

Respect, as most of the "foreign teachers" know it, does not seem to exist in these students' lives.

As we're preparing our students for a Western-style education--and as I have reflected with countless colleagues--these students do not seem capable of having free-time without unleashing pandemonium. In other words, they NEED structure to keep them in place and for them to channel their creativity and energies in more productive ways. For example I had to teach a lesson to my 7th graders on how to rehearse (step by step!) because they did not know how to do it on their own; when left on their own, they goofed off.

Perhaps this is where we could apply the concept of Parker Palmer's paradox (The Courage to Teach): there are many situations where two seemingly opposite sides exist. Structure is necessary, but it is meaningless without the creative/free component (freedom within structure).

Could Discipline, Structure, Independence, and Creativity Coexist? Yes - in fact, they must!

Identity Crisis: Asian, American, Musician, Educator

Lately I've been feeling conflicted as there are many things that go unspoken while interacting with students, other parents, and teachers in China. It has been challenging for me to stand firm in what I believe in; if I don't stand firm, I fail to be the teacher and person that I want to be. Here are a few of my observations (conflicts):

• Many Chinese kids AND adults cannot believe that I'm from America; I am Asian [Taiwanese] American. The externalized attempt to comprehend usually goes like this: "Your Chinese sounds off, but I can still talk with you and you know what I am saying...you look Chinese...but you say you're American...how come you're not white? You can't be American..." I find conversations like this to be amusing.
• When I tell others (Chinese relatives, other parents, the Chinese teachers, etc.) that I am a music teacher, they usually follow-up by asking me: "What kind of music do you teach? Will you teach them to play the piano - maybe sing?" All I can do is nod and smile. I don't have the vocabulary to tell them the philosophical underpinnings of what I do, so I just tell them those are possibilities.
• When I tell people my Chinese name (汤耀中 - Tāng Yào Zhōng), I usually explain what each character represents (it's the Chinese way of introducing names). "Tāng as in soup - this is my surname. Yào as in glorify. Zhōng as in, the character used in China; middle; center." And everybody's immediate response is, "Great! You're bringing glory to China!" Boy, does this gets on my nerves! I have revised the last part of my explanation and taken China out of it.
• I feel that my fellow foreign teachers are able to get away with more as they are unable to speak to many of the Chinese teachers. Moreover, they look and act different enough that they are acknowledged and accepted as "different." On the other hand, since I can speak and hear Chinese, I have realized how much I disagree with the Chinese way of doing things in conversations and as I overhear others' conversations. It's a strange dilemma: I want to connect, yet, the more I connect the more I feel uncomfortable; part of me wishes to remain oblivious.
• My elementary students were confused as I played musical games with them last week: "How is this music class?" The students here are used to drilling, reciting, and sitting at desks (some of the Chinese teachers are still doing this as they teach, even if it conflicts with the school's mission statement). I guess this is just something that needs to be worked on one step at a time.
• The Chinese view music as something that only the talented and focused few can do (and music class is only about the talent and skill); it is exclusive. I am trying to make music accessible to everyone. These two frames of mind do not gel together very well. (I am working with a few Chinese music teachers - I foresee this being particularly difficult to navigate)

The big questions: what does it mean for me to stay true to myself? What is my role as a teacher within a larger school system: to be a follower, or a leader? How do I navigate through a world where I don't really belong?

I was hired by the "international principal," an alumna of Teachers College, to bring the Western perspective of music (or, to bring Western education and philosophy through music), yet I feel that I am situated in a context where all odds are against me. At the same time, I'd like to believe that Teachers College has prepared me to stand for myself, stay grounded in theory and philosophy, and to likewise help students find their individual "voices." I know Teachers College tends to raise leaders and advocates in their fields; I believe I am now in a position to slowly bring change to the culture here (the foreign/international administrators are, in fact, encouraging me to do so). The thought of this both excites and terrifies me.

God, help me.

Great Eats: 花中城 (Huā Zhōng Chéng - Flower City)

This post was meant to be completed a couple weeks ago, apologies for the slight delay. With that said:

花中城 (located in Shangcheng, Hangzhou) has many affordable but delicious options ranging from desserts to seafood, and everything else. This 11-part meal ended up costing only ~$30 (US)! My relatives originally brought me here during my first week in Hangzhou; turns out my coworkers come here often too since it's so close to our school!

A dessert dish (a fruit jelly)

Fried shrimp cakes - this was one of my favorites!

Standard greens

Fried taro pastry - a tasty dessert!

Hangzhou duck - another great dish!

String Beans

Some kind of Fish from Hangzhou

More fish

A Hangzhou soup with three "rarities"

 

"Tofu skin" - another tasty option (I grew up eating this)!

Didn't get the name off the menu, but this is basically a steamed cake - very spongy

Reflections on My First Week of Class

Hey everyone, I'm about to begin my second of week of school, but just to give everyone an update and for me to reflect on what I experienced last week:

What: Two 7th grade music classes (class size 12-13)
Where: At the WeLearning Center (the new school is still under construction), 未来城。
When: Alternating days (class A one day, class B another day, etc.), from Sunday to Friday (there was a make-up work day for a holiday last week)
How: Using no musical instruments, a whiteboard, markers, my iPhone, a speaker system, and paper. Decided to take an Orff(-ish) approach.



Here are my lesson plans that I used (please excuse any possible errors):

 9/6/15

Class: 7th Grade General Music

Unit (Central Focus): Introductions – Who Are We? How Is Music Relevant To Us?

Objectives: Students will learn more about each other, and I will get to know the students. Students will learn basic rules for a musical classroom (LISTEN).

Standards: (Doesn’t matter for now)

Materials: Survey Sheets (x25), iPhone (to play music), Audio System, Pencils (?), Pen, Whiteboard, Markers

Duration: 60 minutes

Anticipatory Set: (5 minutes) Quickly go around and ask students for their name and their favorite thing in music – artist, genre, instruments, etc. I will share a little bit more about myself.

Part 1: (10 minutes) ·      Name Game: “My mama told me to tell you to say your name just like I do.” (x2) o   Show kids an example (“Do it with me”) o   Go around – then ask, “What kinds of different things were your classmates doing?” Write on whiteboard, for them to think about it. o   Try it one more time, but this time try something different.

Part 2: (5 minutes) ·      Quick discussion: o   Were we doing music? What does it mean to be musical? o   What are things we need to keep in mind while doing music? §  Possibilities: listen, be intentional, don’t ruin it for everybody, wait your turn, participate, try, respect each other, be supportive, etc. (write on board)

Part 3: (25 minutes) ·      Survey Game (Similarities and Differences) o   Spend 4 minutes filling out the survey (passing out, doing, etc.) o   Now, gather in groups when I tell you the category; as big of a group as you can! Look for: SIMILAR RESPONSES or DIFFERENT RESPONSES o   Just so it doesn’t get too chaotic, what are things we need to keep in mind? No shouting across the room, don’t push each other over. o   This will be TIMED (like musical chairs). Brownie points if you could recognize the song being played! ·      Discussion: go through responses one at a time, giving space to each individual. Open up the space for questions, comments, responses, etc. ·      At the end, I will share my responses too. ·      Leave extra time at the end for questions.

Independent Practice: ·      None.

9/8/15

Class: 7th Grade General Music

Unit (Central Focus): Basics of Music (Beat, Rhythms, Tempo)

Objectives: Students will gain understanding and play with: beat, rhythm, doo, doo-day

Standards: (Doesn’t matter for now)

Materials: Whiteboard, Marker, Timer, Blank Beat Template (2 sheets) cut, Scissors

Duration: 60 minutes

Anticipatory Set: (10 minutes) ·      Human Knot Game o   Divide into 2 groups (of 6 each) o   Explain rules (unknot yourselves, without letting go of hands) o   Go! (Compete) Then try doing it as a class.

Teaching: (25 minutes) ·      Introduce the word: Beat o   “A beat is a unit of time in music.” o   Here is a steady beat: (Clap, etc.) Let’s clap together. o   Provide the visual component (lines on the board) – try different ones! ·      Introduce the word: Rhythm o   “Rhythms are patterns that fit into beats.” o   We will learn two: “Du” and “Du-de” (Write visual on board) o   Repeat after me: (Say the rhythms, and clap the beat) – build it up. ·      Assessment: in PAIRS (set up expectations at this time!), I will give you a written rhythm, using the system we used today. I want you and your partner to say it and perform it together. Clap the beat, say “Du” and “Du-de.” o   Perform for class!

Guided Practice: (20 minutes) ·      Pass out blank beat sheets (8 lines) and have pairs of students come up with their own rhythms! ·      They will then give the rhythm to another group, and will receive new ones themselves. ·      Practice the rhythm—performance quality! ·      Performance: SET EXPECTATIONS (how can we be a good audience?) o   Have the entire class decode it together (I will ask a student to be the scribe). o   Compare what we have on the board with what was written on the paper.

Closing: (5 minutes) ·      We’ll chill—let students ask me questions (just talk at this point – building rapport, speaking in English, etc.).

Independent Practice: ·      None.

9/10/15

Class: 7th Grade General Music

Unit (Central Focus): Basics of Music (Beat, Rhythms, Tempo)

Objectives: Students will apply concepts from the last lesson (beat, rhythm) into new contexts.

Standards: (Doesn’t matter for now)

Materials: Whiteboard, Marker, Stuffed Animals (variety), Homework Assignments, Animaniacs Nations of the World video!

Duration: 60 minutes

Anticipatory Set: (15 minutes) ·      Welcome students, gather in a circle! ·      Take out a stuffed animal, and tell them the exact steps. Start with one student, pass it to another while saying their name (across from you!) ·      Make one round through, don’t give them too much yet (the goal is to go all the way through). ·      Ramp it up, add one more stuffed animal. ·      Go until we are challenged – ask: what can we do? (Communicate, eye contact, keep a beat, etc.)

Teaching: (15 minutes) ·      Review beat, rhythm, syllable. ·      Review a couple of examples. ·      We will then dissect different words and write the rhythms for them. Starting with my example (Composition). Have a couple of other words prepared (Homework, etc.) and go through the process with the students. o   Assessment: Go around to each student and ask each to prepare one word (how many beats? What is the rhythm?)

Practice: (20 minutes) ·      Continent chant: tell them that I wrote a chant for them! We will dissect it together. ·      We will learn it and give them time to practice on their own. These are the seven continents: North and South America, Asia, Europe, Africa, Then there is Australia, And finally Antarctica. These are the seven continents! ·      Review performance etiquette (don’t begin until performers are paying attention, follow the leader). Try performing!

Closing: (10 minutes) ·      Pass out the assignment – see if all kids understand. Run through instructions with them. ·      End with the Animaniacs video

Independent Practice: ·      Homework assignment (will quiz them next week).

Name:

Date:

7^th Grade Music Survey

1) What is your favorite genre of music?

2) Do you play any instruments (or sing, compose, DJ, etc.)? Provide a list:

3) What does the word “music” mean to you?

4) What do you know about music? Anything/everything:

5) What was the last song you listened to on your music player?

6) What kinds of musical experiences have you had? Provide a list:

7) What do you like about music?

8) What do you dislike about music?

9) What would you like to get out of music class this year?

10) Is there anything else you’d like to tell us?

Name:

Date:

7^th Grade Music Homework #1

New Words:

Beat: a unit of time in music.

Rhythm: patterns that fit into beats.

Syllable: the number of sounds in a word (example: “homework” has 2 syllables).

Composition: a written piece of music.

Audience: the listeners of a musical performance.

Du: One syllable, the length of 1 beat (        )

Du-De: two syllables, also the length of 1 beat (        )

Rest: A space in music; the beat continues underneath.

Questions:

1) What are the three parts of being a good audience member?

            1.

2.

           

3.

2) Practice these examples (use “Du” and “Du-De”); you will be tested during the next class.

 (NOTE: TEACHER WILL WRITE RHYTHMS)

a)                                                                                                                                                 . 

b)                                                                                                                                                 . 

c)                                                                                                                                                 . 

3) What is the rhythm of the word or set of words? The first is done as an example:

            1. Audience                                                            5. Inch

2. Sketch Book                                                6. World Map

           

3. Beat                                                                        7. Equal Ratio

            4. Horizontal                                                            8. Pencil

4) Create a composition using each of these: Du, Du-de, Rest. Optional: use the words above in the composition (write the words beneath the lines). Prepare to perform this piece.

                                                                                                                                                .